“Paid to be family”: Do Shared Lives schemes engage Article 8 rights?

The courts have taken the position that Article 8 rights are not automatic in fostering arrangements (either for adults or for children) but can arise as a consequence of the nature, duration and strength of the relationships.

An “Avoiding Restraint” Plan for a 17-year-old facing caesarean section

Rather than starting with the question of how AB might be restrained, she insisted that thought be given first to how to avoid putting AB in situations where restraint might become necessary.

Final hearing in the ‘vile judgment’ case: Coming full circle

By Daniel Clark, Amanda Hill and Celia Kitzinger, 8th November 2026 The final hearing in this long-running case lasted 16 minutes. The case began with an application from Norfolk County Council on 18th December 2023 and came to an end nearly three years later, after 10 hearings [Note: Caroline corrects us and say it wasContinue reading “Final hearing in the ‘vile judgment’ case: Coming full circle”

Two siblings face imminent eviction due to care home closure: A race against time and a local authority lacking urgency

The new owners of the small care home the siblings live in have announced that they will be closing the care home in a few short weeks. A new home has to be found for the siblings, urgently. This case displays the limits of the Court of Protection, the immense pressure on social services, and the harm being caused to vulnerable people.

Covert recording and contact restrictions

Gravely concerned about her son’s care, the mother had resorted to covert recording by giving her son a teddy bear with a hidden device inside. But when the covert recording was revealed, the Health Board stopped contact between mother and son, and made an application for an interim injunction to prohibit her from recording in future and to re-establish a (restricted) contact regime.

Everyone agrees it’s in the best interests of two siblings to live together – but is that possible?

By Daniel Clark and Amanda Hill, 29th October 2026 Two siblings, AA and BB, have lived together almost all their lives and now reside in the same care home. However, one has been served with an eviction notice and there is therefore a risk that they’ll be separated. It now falls to the Court ofContinue reading “Everyone agrees it’s in the best interests of two siblings to live together – but is that possible?”

Contesting deprivation of liberty post-AGNI: Not a marginal case but “the very exemplar of why the state is under an obligation to provide safeguards”, says HHJ Hilder

BW is objecting as loudly and frequently as her condition enables her to do. I agree with Ms Butler-Cole that this is not  a marginal situation.  This is the  very exemplar of why the state is under an obligation to provide safeguards.

Two non-compliance hearings concerning Finance Deputyship applications: Finding pragmatic ways forward

By Celia Kitzinger, 23rd October 2026 There were five hearings concerning ‘non-compliance with court orders’ listed, for 15 minutes each, before DJ Ellington sitting remotely at First Avenue House on Monday 19th October 2026.  I watched two of them, at 11am and 12.30pm.[1] ­­­­Both hearings concerned family members who’d made applications to become Deputies for PropertyContinue reading “Two non-compliance hearings concerning Finance Deputyship applications: Finding pragmatic ways forward”

“Wrapped in Cotton Wool”: Protection, Restriction and P’s Best Interests

Following years of serious illness, B’s parents had created what the judge described as a “cocoon of happiness” around their daughter. The difficult question before the court was whether preserving that cocoon truly served B’s best interests or whether accepting the risks of elective surgery could offer her the opportunity for a fuller and less restricted life.

“Complete failure” of Fit to Discharge proceedings before Lieven J: Carers suspended, allegations of abuse, and no immediate prospect of discharge

The judge struggles to see how things could be worse. Allegations of abuse have been made against the carers, a safeguarding investigation is underway, the care agency has suspended six staff, and the LA has terminated the contract. Oh, and the hospital where P’s been for 14 months now has a ‘superbug’ infection and P’s tested positive.