By Daniel Clark, 2nd October 2024 The protected party in this case, “B”, is a thirty-year-old woman who, according to Counsel for her mother, has until recently been a “happy, well balanced, sociable person”. She enjoys spending time with her family and, until 2024, had been living with her mother at home. This case (COP 14116349)Continue reading “Closed hearings, safeguarding concerns, and financial interests v. best interests”
Tag Archives: Best Interests
Why can’t a 91-year old return home to her son?
By Celia Kitzinger and Kim Dodd, 30th September 2024 Now with updating PostScript, 13th December 2024 We both watched this hearing (COP 20000918) on 30 September 2024 before HHJ Robertshaw in Bristol concerning a 91-year-old lady (P) who has been deprived of her liberty in hospital for several months, as a “social admission” (i.e. there’sContinue reading “Why can’t a 91-year old return home to her son? “
Can a Turkish Guardianship Order be recognised in England and Wales?
By Daniel Clark, 29 September 2024 This case began as an urgent application to the Court of Protection in August 2023. It wasn’t until May 2024 that it came before a judge. In August 2023, XY (who resides in Turkey) was visiting the UK with her brother, CD. She has done this many times but,Continue reading “Can a Turkish Guardianship Order be recognised in England and Wales? “
Balancing open justice and P’s right to privacy: A protected party says NO to a public observer “and her voice shall be heard”
By Eleanor Tallon, 3rd September 2024 Editorial Note: The judgment (making this hearing private) has now been published: Stockport MBC v NN & Anor [2024] EWCOP 51 (T1) I was not able to observe this hearing because the protected party, N, said she did not want an observer as “she doesn’t know who they are orContinue reading “Balancing open justice and P’s right to privacy: A protected party says NO to a public observer “and her voice shall be heard””
A “Catch 22” situation for P or Hobson’s Choice? Disagreement among professionals as to whether P has capacity and a finely balanced decision for the judge
By Amanda Hill, 30th August 2024 “I want to get on with my life”. At the heart of this hearing (COP 14251478 on 20th August 2024) is P, a man who looks to be in his late 60s or early 70s. He attended remotely by video link from a psychiatric hospital and was present for most ofContinue reading “A “Catch 22” situation for P or Hobson’s Choice? Disagreement among professionals as to whether P has capacity and a finely balanced decision for the judge “
Capacity, Relaxing of Restrictions, and a Happy P!
By Hita Jadeja, 28th August 2024 I observed a hearing on 24th July 2024 (COP 13879770) before His Honour Judge Whybrow who was sitting remotely (via Cloud Video Platform [CVP]) as a nominated Court of Protection judge at the County Court and Family Court at Kingston upon Hull. The protected party (P) in this caseContinue reading “Capacity, Relaxing of Restrictions, and a Happy P!”
Tangled webs, ‘enmeshment’, and breakdown of trust: Re A: (Covert medication: Closed Proceedings) – an implementation hearing
By Claire Martin, 18 August 2024 This case (COP 13236134) has been in the Court of Protection since 2018. The protected party (A) is a 25-year-old woman, who has been living in a care home under a Court of Protection order, for five years. If all goes according to plan, she will be back atContinue reading “Tangled webs, ‘enmeshment’, and breakdown of trust: Re A: (Covert medication: Closed Proceedings) – an implementation hearing “
Directions Hearing for a Life Sustaining Treatment Case
By Hita Jadeja, 14th August 2024 On 31 July 2024 I observed a hearing (COP 20000664) before Mrs Justice Theis sitting at the Royal Courts of Justice. An NHS Trust (‘the Trust’) has made an application concerning life-sustaining treatment for a middle-aged lady and this was a ‘directions’ hearing. Essentially directions hearings are held to prepareContinue reading “Directions Hearing for a Life Sustaining Treatment Case”
Marking one’s own homework: A “fair-minded observer’s” view of a recusal refusal
by Daniel Clark, 13th August 2024 What can a party do if they feel that, during the course of a hearing, they were “silenced and bullied and berated” by the judge? What happens if a litigant in person thinks that the judge is taking advantage of her lack of representation and “colluding” with the local authority? Continue reading “Marking one’s own homework: A “fair-minded observer’s” view of a recusal refusal”
She wants to tell her Court of Protection story but will the court allow her?
By Amanda Hill, 6th August 2024 This is a blog about an application to change (“vary”) a Transparency Order, the order restricting what can be reported from a Court of Protection hearing. Unlike many other blog posts about applications to change Transparency Orders, the application this time isn’t from a member of the Open Justice Court ofContinue reading “She wants to tell her Court of Protection story but will the court allow her? “
Promoting Open Justice in the Court of Protection 