By Elissa Novak and Brittany Murphy 4th July 2025 Editorial Note (Celia Kitzinger): The hearing took place over two days on 24th and 25th June 2025, and there was a shifting group of six or so observers, some of whom took part in discussion about the case which contributed to the ideas expressed in thisContinue reading “No more force (or threat of force) to compel feeding of woman with severe and enduring anorexia”
Tag Archives: Best Interests
Navigating engagement in capacity assessment
By Daniel Holt, 2nd July 2025 The case I observed in person before District Judge Clarke sitting at First Avenue House on 9th June 2025 (COP 20015914) was brought by the London Borough of Lewisham (the “LA”) and concerned a deaf adult with a mild learning disability (“P”), who was represented by the Official SolicitorContinue reading “Navigating engagement in capacity assessment”
Strongly held beliefs do not equate to lack of litigation capacity: Judgment concerning Luba Macpherson’s appeal against committal to prison
By Amanda Hill, 24th June 2024 “But in America, in my home, they are persecuting people for using their right to free speech and voicing their dissent. This is happening now.” (Bruce Springsteen, during his concert at Lille, Saturday 24 May 2025[1]) As well as saying people are persecuted for using their right to freeContinue reading “Strongly held beliefs do not equate to lack of litigation capacity: Judgment concerning Luba Macpherson’s appeal against committal to prison”
“Does that mean I am off the hook?”: A successful s21a Deprivation of Liberty Challenge
By Claire Martin, 23rd June 2025 I had some unexpected time on Monday 16th June 2025, so I had a look at the listings the night before, and this one caught my eye because it said ‘FINAL HEARING’, so I knew that the judge’s determination on the matters listed (‘capacity and best interests’) was likelyContinue reading ““Does that mean I am off the hook?”: A successful s21a Deprivation of Liberty Challenge”
Preparing for possible future lack of capacity: My advance decision to refuse treatment and the case before Poole J
By Claire Martin, 13th June 2025 Le soleil ni la mort ne se peuvent regarder en face. You cannot stare straight into the face of the sun, or death. François de La Rochefoucauld, Maxim 26 Over the course of the last year or so, I’ve been thinking about what provisions I want to put inContinue reading “Preparing for possible future lack of capacity: My advance decision to refuse treatment and the case before Poole J”
A judge without a bundle adjourns the case
By Daniel Clark, 11th June 2025 A bundle is a collection of documents that are relevant to the decision that the court is being asked to make. As Kyle Squire, then a barrister at 5 Pump Court Chambers put it in a blog for the Open Justice Court of Protection Project, “‘Bundle’ may be aContinue reading “A judge without a bundle adjourns the case”
Risk aversion and delay: Losing sight of best interests?
By Rebecca Pritchard, 2nd June 2025 I have observed a number of Court of Protection hearings but have never blogged one before. I chose to blog about this case (COP 14265088 heard by Lieven J on 6th May 2025 in the Royal Courts of Justice, observed via MS Teams), because firstly, it struck me asContinue reading “Risk aversion and delay: Losing sight of best interests?”
Unsuccessful Application for Permission to Appeal
By Claire Martin, 19th May 2025 In May 2024, a year ago, Amanda Hill blogged about this case: “The protected party in this case (“L”) is a man in his twenties with “significant learning disability”, autism and complex physical disabilities. He had been living at home with a care package in place until July 2021, whenContinue reading “Unsuccessful Application for Permission to Appeal”
DJ Clarke calls time on public body delay: Internet restrictions, consultation with deputies, and a rejection of judicial “micromanaging”
By Daniel Clark, 16th May 2025 This case concerns XY: an autistic man in his twenties who lived an active and sociable life until a decline in his mental health. As described in an earlier blog post, he’s been failed by NHS South West London ICB and the London Borough of Wandsworth. The issue before theContinue reading “DJ Clarke calls time on public body delay: Internet restrictions, consultation with deputies, and a rejection of judicial “micromanaging””
Validity and applicability of an Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment: A pre-trial review
By Celia Kitzinger, 14th May 2025 Editorial note: There is a now published judgment, following the later hearing of 22nd and 23rd May) (which will be blogged separately). Click on the link in the name of the case: Re AB (ADRT: Validity and Applicability) [2025] EWCOP 20 (T3) The man at the centre of thisContinue reading “Validity and applicability of an Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment: A pre-trial review”
Promoting Open Justice in the Court of Protection 